Showing posts with label Merger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Merger. Show all posts

Thursday, November 29, 2012

5 Reasons Why Charity Mergers Work

Based on the for-profit track record, charities should stay away from mergers. Given that many academic studies find that a large proportion of for-profit mergers actually decrease profits and efficiency why would charitable organizations risk this path?

As discussed previously merging charities has risks, but I'm increasingly of the opinion that the benefits outweigh the challenges. Here are 5 key reasons why merging can and does make sense.

  1. Like-minded organizations that come together to focus on a single issue or cause can accomplish far more than each working alone. What's been called "collective impact" is all the buzz right now in the charitable world simply because it works: just ask Advancing Philanthropy!
  2. My contention is that there are simply too many charities - think about the number of different organizations that have overlapping Missions or seek to duplicate the work already being done by another group.  With 161,000 charities and non-profits in Canada alone surely there's room for fewer to do better work with reduced confusion and re-work.
  3. In the spirit of reduced confusion, clearly mergers would allow precious donor dollars to be more accurately and effectively applied.  And the obverse is that fewer charities would also allow donor dollars to support more impact and less overhead: two charities that merge into one only need one photocopier, one reception area, and one kitchen microwave, not two of each.  Also, with fewer competing messages for donations it would be easier (and more cost effective) for vital charitable messages to break through and be heard.
  4. The charitable world is all about passion, but like money there are only so many volunteers and so many donated hours to go around.  A merged organization would (ideally) draw on the strengths that existed in the originals, ensuring that 1+1=3.
  5. The best reason to pursue mergers, collaboration and collective impact in the charitable world is that it's very hard to do.  Albeit a simplification, in the for profit world the firm with enough money can buy out the one that's smaller.  In the charitable world that doesn't work (donor backlash, government regulations, volunteer boards, etc.), and organizations that seek to "merge" need to find common ground and shared passion.  The same volunteers and varied stakeholders that can make decision-making within charities so challenging present natural barriers to ill-considered collaborations.  So the fact that it takes so much work and trust to merge mean that it is likely the outcomes will be better in the long run.  Remember, money can't buy you love...
I'm personally aware of several great examples where charity mergers, collaboration and collective impact are already working well, and expect we'll see more examples in this tough economy. It appears that 1+1 does indeed equal 3.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Charitable Mergers: A recipe for change, challenge and opportunity

Here’s a recipe we should all be thinking about… Take thousands of charities, dozens of great causes, and bring to a boil through limited financial resources and increasing demand. Blend in a desire to leverage for-profit best practices around mergers and you have the potential for a tasty dish to serve many new stakeholders. But how do you ensure that the dish ever even gets made, and if so how do you ensure it doesn’t boil over to make a huge mess?

Corporate mergers often fail. And charities that have been poorly merged have failed too. Moreover, the same passion that is at the core of every successful charity can actively resist the kind of change required for a merger. Worse yet, very real issues of maintaining donors and ensuring long-time supporters don’t leave can scare off even veteran Boards and charitable leaders.

Here are three top ways to help make this process less intimidating and more likely to succeed.

First, seek what is common in the charities in question as opposed to strictly what is different. Craig Dearden-Phillips’ article http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/feb/17/charity-merger-journey
sheds light on this perspective.

Second, seek engagement from corporate funders in particular early in the process. With the growing trend towards Collective Impact http://www.ssireview.org/articles/entry/collective_impact/ corporate funders are beginning to "reward" organizations that are considering ways to "do more" with combined resources.

Finally, consider all your stakeholders and communicate a vision that underscores benefits (even if it may only be survival) for all concerned. Collaboration, transparency and openness have helped other organizations achieve success http://www.insidetoronto.com/print/43149 and are the key ingredients of successful corporate mergers as well.

Not undertaken lightly or without risk, a charitable merger – even of one function or via shared space – might be worth your consideration on the menu at least as “food for thought”.

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Day of Reckoning?

Conversations after my last post made me think that perhaps I left too negative an impression. The societal, economic and "evolutionary" pressures converging on our multitude of charities will result in massive change.  I stand by my statement that a day of reckoning will come, particularly for the tens of thousands of charities, particularly smaller ones, that struggle to make ends meet every day.

But my sense is that smaller charities that are smart and innovative - and in particular well led charities of all sizes - will find a way to thrive.

First, after some meetings recently about Social Finance, I believe there are some wonderful and highly entrepreneurial ways we can meet this challenge.  This video at http://vimeo.com/8057258 covers the general outlines of Social Finance very well.

Simiarly, I've always been impressed by the work of organizations that encourage donors to think critically about their giving... To the degree giving from the heart and the head grows we may see greater innovation and social impact in the long term.  One good site for this sort of information is http://www.charityintelligence.ca/ 

A day of reckoning is looming, but it need not necessarily be one of disasterous proportions.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Charities: Size Does Matter

One of the more common questions for those considering a move from the for-profit world into the philanthropic sector is about the pay, and the nature of the roles. I'm going to share some "truths" about these questions, and expand into some thoughts about the future of the entire sector.

First, it is true that many well-compensated people will make less money working for a charity than they made in the for-profit world. As everyone has heard, part of the reward of working in this sector is knowing you're making a difference, and often the sense that you're following your "calling", and for reasons I'm not entirely clear on this translates into less pay. The best explanation I can come up with is that because charities operate with other people's donated money, and the fact that every dollar spent on salaries is a dollar less for the mission, we tend to undercompensate employees. More on this strategy and the implications to the sector another day...

Second, there is usually a direct correlation between the size of the charity (e.g. top-line gross revenue) and their ability to pay a reasonable wage. Big hospitals, universities and "name" charities (Heart, Cancer, etc.) have the capacity to pay more than the little theatre troupe down the street.

None of this is news, but there has been a trend towards more competitive pay to attract and retain top talent. Senior positions in a charity are incredibly complex and challenging, so ensuring appropriate compensation is a vital factor – something the for-profit world has known for a long time. This has led to occasional mistakes in judgement in terms of just how much donors are willing to support for salaries, but except for these examples there has been a trend upwards in terms of salaries. And it’s the bigger charities that can most afford this cost, so keep that in mind if you’re out looking to make the transition.

This size conversation leads to my final point. The economy is struggling. Government is deep in debt and less eager to make significant investments in the charitable sector. The big charities want to keep growing. All of this puts massive pressure on the thousands of little charities that are struggling to make ends meet across Canada every day. My sense is that a "day of reckoning" is coming, and that charities below a certain size will face enormous pressure to gain critical mass, to merge with other charities, or to find some other synergistic way to reduce costs in the next 3-5 years, or they simply won’t survive. So size matters in another way: in a sector with nearly 100,000 competitors, and with new entrants every day, when the food supply shrinks (e.g. funding) then some tough times are likely ahead.  For those considering a move into the philanthropic sector size may be a key consideration.