Showing posts with label complexity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label complexity. Show all posts

Sunday, June 24, 2012

Insights Into the Charitable World: A Primer

According to Imagine Canada the non-profit and voluntary sector in Canada generates 7.8% of our GDP. So not only is the sector interesting for people who want to make a difference in our world, it's big enough to garner the attention of those who want to help by offering services and making a profit while doing so.  But it's big enough, complex enough and has enough unique aspects to make it frustrating to understand or even impenetrable to those who don't already know it well.

So following from a presentation last week to one of Canada's largest banks and their "Not For Profit & Public Sector" team, I thought you might want to have at least a few of the sources and links that I provided them.  Here is a short list of the resources, thought provoking reads and issues on our mind that you could use to sharpen your understanding of the non-profit and voluntary sector in Canada and abroad.

  • There's really only one national "voice" for the charitable and non-profit world in Canada, and Imagine Canada's website is the place to go for all of their links, tools and resources.
  • In a sector challenged by limitless demand and (in many cases) diminishing resources, doing more with less is a good idea. Stanford's Social Innovation Review's article on Collective Impact is a great place to delve into this concept.
  • Fundraising is the engine that fuels the good works that charities do, and the best research I know of about retaining donors and what makes donors give is done by Cygnus Applied Research.  Penelope Burk is the founder, and her website is a great resource.
  • As charities seek innovative new ways to raise funds, "revenue diversification" has been a common phrase. If Social Enterprise is one of the diversification options on your radar, or if you've never heard the phrase, the Social Finance Census 2010 is a good place to learn more.
  • For a thought-provoking look at the charitable world and to quickly get up to speed on some of the hot-button issues we face today, I recommend Dan Pallotta's Uncharitable as a good resource.  Not specific to Canada, he nevertheless asks questions that apply just as much here as south of the border.
Finally, I'd like to highlight the willingness to learn and desire to help the Not For Profit and Public Sector that drives the team I met from Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) last week.  Good for you, and thanks for furthering the important work that our sector strives to effect!

Friday, January 28, 2011

New Year's Top 10 List - Differences in the Charitable World

I got off the phone this morning with a woman who is thinking about making the move from the for profit world into the charitable world. At the root of most of our conversation was the question "just how do the two differ?" So in the spirit of New Year "Top 10" lists, here’s my Top 10 List of for-profit versus charitable differences. Note that I’m not going for the obviously different aspects, but what might surprise you on the "other side"….


  1. Passion – in the charitable world it’s about wanting to make a difference. People, inspired by their experiences or insight into a need, set out to change the world. Not make a profit: change the world.
  2. Mission – most corporate employees don’t know their corporate Mission statement. Most charitable employees live their Mission statement every day. This affects every aspect of the charity.
  3. Volunteers – are a key defining difference. Most charities simply could not exist without what volunteers bring: their skills, their passion, their heart and they’re free. This all has its own set of intrinsic pros and cons, but whatever the case I don’t remember many volunteers helping out the corporations where I worked
  4. Boards – sure big corporations often have Boards, but unlike the vast majority of businesses charities of all sizes have Boards
  5. Complexity – given that charities have Boards and volunteers, and structures or staff that parallel virtually all for-profit activities, charities of roughly the same operating budgets (size) as a for-profit business are more complex
  6. Structure – at the same time, in comparing most organizations of a similar size, my experience is that charities are relatively unstructured for their size (e.g. fewer policies and manuals, less robust Human Resources practices, etc.)
  7. Lean – if you think your for-profit experience was with a lean organization, I’m pretty sure there are still charities that can show you a trick or two. All funds (for better and for worse) are often pushed to the furtherance of the Mission
  8. Intangible – a bit of an "obvious" difference but with important implications, unlike many for-profit organizations what is "sold" in a charity is a feeling or outcome, not a "thing". For example, this difference results in different skills for fundraisers versus salespeople
  9. Voice – manufacturing has a sector voice, but in Canada non-profit is even bigger but with less "clout" (and same as the automotive sector) – Imagine Canada does great work as one voice (and in U.S. not even a single voice at all), but as evidence of this difference no Federal bail-out money was coming to struggling charities in this economic downturn
  10. Understanding – most Canadians have a fairly good sense of the ingredients in the food they buy, or the "value" of property they live in, but most don’t understand the causes they support as well. If buying something and making a gift are both transactions of a kind, the difference here is that purchases are often made first through the head, while donations are often made first through the heart.
Not better or worse, but very different indeed!